From FB: Debat lebih baik daripada Muzakarah?

Amin Ahmad at 5:43pm July 1
maksud nik aziz di sebalik tu ialah libatkan lebih ramai pihak.

Fauzi Shaffie at 5:53pm July 1
kalau debat selalunya antara dua pihak sahaja. Muzakarah boleh lebih drpd satu pihak. Muzakarah ada bawa maksud "negotiation", "consultation", "conference", "deliberation", "learning", "memorizing", "study". Debat drpd BI yang bawa maksud: "to discuss opposing reasons", "argue opposing sides of questions", "to dispute", ....

Mohd Azham Hassan at 6:00pm July 1
just to add up..rasanya kalau "debat", you won't easily get the solution. Tapi, kalau "muzakarah", "perbincangan", ruang penyelesaian akan lebih terbuka...debat Shabery-DSAI, Khairy-Husam.. ada bawak penyelesaiankah?

Syed Nazim Muhamad at 6:00pm July 1
Debat untuk cari pemenang.Yang kalah tak puas hati...sampai bila pun tak boleh setel...Baiklah muzakarah

Amin Ahmad at 6:00pm July 1
itu antara mereka, tapi debat org tak buat tertutup, org buat terbuka. muzakarah tertutup. utk saya debat atau muzakarah ni hanya terma...yg org x selesa ialah bila mereka x tahu content, spekulasi berlaku. kiranya desakan untuk participate dari org ramai.

Zulkiflie Ali at 6:02pm July 1
debate is not better than muzakarah...neither muzakarah is not better than debate... there's giv another meaning for both of them... it's depend on wht,hw,why,who etc...so, the issue is, hw dare r u to let people know tht u r rite or wrong...peace no war...

Fauzi Shaffie at 6:02pm July 1
Muzakarah yang boleh libatkan orang ramai dinamakan forum.

Mohd Azham Hassan at 6:04pm July 1
with current level of political maturity, it better that having discussions or forum, rather than having debates...

Fauzi Shaffie at 6:19pm July 1
Keyword for debate is "opposing sides". Keyword for muzakarah is "remember", "reminding" (dzakara)

Fauzi Shaffie at 6:22pm July 1
Key objective of debate, "to win". Key objective of muzakarah would be "to find solution".

Zulkiflie Ali at 6:38pm July 1
yeah... u r rite... to win and to find solution is totally diff... msuh lam selimut lebih bhaye dari yg terng2an...

Amin Ahmad at 2:06am July 2
agree Fauzi, I put it in the context: baca tulisan Ustaz Nasruddin. I never agree dgn sikap org nak tunjuk mereka lebih Islam - regardless who they are.
MohamedAzmi RasheedKhan likes this.